I rest my case: Facebook’s appeal to the truly stupid

When I wrote here recently about the strange phenomenon of Facebook’s popularity with the self-absorbed (Why Narcissists Love Facebook), not even I could have guessed the apparent scope of the eye-popping stupidity and utter lack of judgement that some Facebook users are actually capable of openly demonstrating.

During several hours of the shocking Stanley Cup riots in downtown Vancouver, for example, a signature feature of the live television news coverage was the sea of bystanders with arms raised capturing countless images of violence, arson and looting via their cell phone cameras. And when the Vancouver Police Department asked the next morning for help in identifying the thugs who had terrorized their beautiful city, the response from outraged Vancouverites was immediate.

Here’s the unbelievable part, however: not only did bystanders send in their cell phone photos of rioters at work, many of the rioters themselves posted incriminating evidence on their own Facebook pages.

Not surprisingly, the curious urge of some to actually boast about their criminal activities via Facebook (complete with corroborating photographic evidence) is now leading to their undoing. At what point did these brainiacs conclude that posting self-incriminating evidence would be a good idea?

Until now, my chief complaint about Facebook was its attraction to those who honestly believe that others want to know every inane detail of their puny lives, things like (I am not kidding):

“I eat gummy bears by tearing them limb from limb and eating their heads last.”

Really? Seriously? Is there any moment or thought or deed that’s not considered so fascinating that some people feel compelled to urgently share it with the globe via the miracle of social media? Including crime?

Recent research on Facebook users published in the journal Computers in Human Behavior reached these less-than-flattering conclusions:

“Facebook users have higher levels of total narcissism, extraversion, exhibitionism and leadership than Facebook non-users. Secondly, individuals with higher scores on exhibitionism also have higher preferences for photos and status updates than for the site’s other features.

“These findings substantiate the proposition that Facebook is particularly appealing for narcissistic and exhibitionistic people. In fact, it could be argued that Facebook specifically gratifies the narcissistic individual’s need to engage in self-promoting and superficial behavior.”

CBC News, in fact, has already reported a number of cases of Vancouver riot suspects being identified based on their own mid-mayhem Facebook photos and admission updates.

Meanwhile, police continue to track down criminals responsible for the June 15th riot that erupted onto the streets of downtown Vancouver after the final hockey game of the Stanley Cup playoffs between the Vancouver Canucks and the visiting (and ultimate Cup-winning) Boston Bruins.

The parents of one Burnaby teenager, for example, have turned him in to Vancouver police alleging he was involved in looting during the riot. The couple decided to contact police about their son after seeing the photos of looting at the downtown Louis Vuitton store that had been posted online.

Another CBC News report told of Vancouverite Ray Irvine, who was shocked to see online photos obviously posted by one of the rioters:

“Like all Vancouverites, I was outraged by the TV news coverage I saw that night. I couldn’t do anything to stop the riots, but I could do something so these criminals would not get away with it. I think they should all be charged and dealt with harshly.

“So when I realized that this young man had posted on his own Facebook page a full account bragging about his riot activities, including statements such as: ‘I torched like seven cars and looted at least three stores!’ – along with his full name and the name of his workplace – I forwarded his Facebook link directly to his employer’s public relations department, as well as to the Vancouver Police Department Tip Line.”

The public naming and shaming seems to be working already, although some more cynical than I am might quietly wonder why the eye witnesses who took the riot photos they’re now sharing did not attempt en masse to stop the thugs instead of laughing, hooting and partying amongst them as we watched on the TV news?

Why didn’t those 100,000 Canucks fans try to flee to safety when they witnessed the first police car torched, or when the first tear gas canister was lobbed into the crowd by Vancouver riot police? The destruction was not merely the work of an angry mob of heartbroken hockey fans on Wednesday night. As the blaring National Post headlines asked Canadians the next morning, above photos of dancing young people posing gleefully in front of overturned cars set ablaze:

“Why Are These People Smiling?”

My guess is that virtually all Vancouverites now feel pretty darned disgusted by these rioting hooligans – and also sickened by the images of tens of thousands who cheered them on. Former cop Dr. Robert Gordon, now the Director of the School of Criminology at Simon Fraser University, explains:

“People are now responding in the way they feel they can make the most difference. The vast majority of Vancouverites are very upset at what happened, and want to identify the people who were involved and have them punished.”

Many Vancouverites are also now empowered with physical evidence of the crime, something that is usually rare, he added.

Vancouver Police Department Chief Jim Chu said six of the rioters have already turned themselves in after their caught-red-handed photos went public, and police are now recommending criminal charges ranging from arson to unlawful assembly. Police say they will continue to use social media like Facebook to track down rioters, arsonists and looters.

Thousands of tips, and almost one million photos to help identify these morons have already poured into the VPD Public Assistance website. A team of 30 officers (including experts using image-matching facial recognition software to compare riot pictures against all provincial drivers license photos) were assigned to the investigation with more expected to be added.

Incriminating riot images that have gone viral already include those showing 17-year old elite athlete and Olympic hopeful Nathan Kotylak, who was filmed with a lighter and a burning rag being stuffed into the gas tank of a police car, later shown fully engulfed in flames while the crowd cheered. Kotylak attends a private school and plays water polo on Canada’s junior national team. But Water Polo Canada announced on Friday that it had suspended the high-level polo player from its national team after his riot activities were broadcast. In a fine example of parental over-protectiveness while splitting hairs, his father, a prominent surgeon, told the media that the photo of Nathan was “misleading” and his son did not light the police car on fire. But the Maple Ridge teen apologized publicly for his actions after speaking to police on Saturday. He told Global BC what he did was “dumb” and that he was merely “caught up in the moment.”

Sad Vancouverites sign boarded windows of looted stores on Georgia Street

And Vancouverites now seem united in both their shame and condemnation of the night’s riot. Hundreds showed up unasked on Thursday morning with brooms and garbage bags to help clear the downtown streets of broken glass and burnt out debris. When plywood boards went up to replace the huge windows of The Bay (Vancouver’s iconic downtown department store that had every one of its main floor windows smashed by looters), Vancouver citizens quickly began covering the plywood with written apologies and thanks to those who had tried to stop the violence. And a Vancouver police car was found this morning blanketed with Post-it notes, each one a scribbled love note to the VPD members from passing pedestrians.

All of which is sweet justice for concerned Vancouverites like Ray Irvine, who described the Stanley Cup rioters this way to CBC News:

“If somebody’s going to be this stupid, they really do deserve to get caught.”


© 2011 Carolyn Thomas The Ethical Nag: Marketing Ethics for the Easily Swayed

See also:



12 thoughts on “I rest my case: Facebook’s appeal to the truly stupid

  1. Carolyn, I’m so glad to see you posted this. When I heard about the rioting, I thought of you ONLY because you live there and it’s YOUR town and any of us would be just as incensed as you are by the action the night after the Stanley Cup.

    I’m not a sport fan of any kind and I’ve never understood the downtown rioting in any town (win or lose) after a major event. Celebration? Of course! Burning and looting your own community businesses? Some kind of stupid. But then to post on FB. Beyond stupid. Lock ’em away on a desert island….. I don’t want to pay for their room and board in prison! And make them pay every cent of the damages!

    • Thanks for your comment, Lynn. The general feeling here is that the ringleaders of the Stanley Cup riots were not ‘sore loser’ Canucks fans, but a small core of anarchist thugs who brought weapons, masks, and accelerants downtown with them. Vancouver’s mayor told the media: “Roving bands of anarchists and troublemakers bent on havoc set fires, broke windows and whipped up booze-fuelled mobs to create the worst riot in Vancouver’s history.” An absolutely tragic night in a beautiful city.

  2. Actually Carolyn I run a Facebook site (JungCentral) that appears to appeal to folks interested in intellectual content…

    Clearly, your article suggests just how non-thinking some Facebook users can be – there is also a place on Facebook for folks wanting to share information of value, rather than say, talking about ripping gummy bears apart from limb to limb.

    I hope there is eventually some Facebook/Skype/GoogleChat combo that eventually makes it possible for people to share and discuss ideas and information online not of a narcissistic nature, but in a way that increases social cohesion, support, and so on…

    The current support groups online for health issues, for instance, are quite limited in their ability to provide an in-depth sense of community, although certainly they are helpful at a basic level.

    Looking forwarding to being your Friend on Facebook for Boomers when technology online gets 3-D and is truly virtual…..


    • Hi Steve – You may be right, but the vast majority of active Facebook users are currently the age 18-34 demographic (just like those participating in the Vancouver riots). Let me know when Facebook for Boomers gets here, okay? 😉

  3. I found myself here after following a current responder on another website. Not being a fan of facebook due to the extreme levels of self absorption and mind bleeding levels of excruciating minutia practiced by the majority of its cult, I found great enjoyment in reading your take on both facebook and even more so the riots in Vancouver.

    Your story was every bit as inviting, professional and informative as any journalist writing on the subject and in providing such a fine story you have found yourself a new reader. I look forward to reading more of your opinions.

  4. Just because certain idiots use Facebook to post their riot activities (duh…) doesn’t mean that ALL people on Facebook are idiots too. And this is not what you’re saying anyway right?

    I think it just means that if you do happen to be an idiot or a moron or a stupid self-centred rioter, you’re probably one of those who really really really like updating your Facebook account A LOT. I think your thots on the Van. riots both on this post and on others I’ve read here are brilliant by the way. Way to call it like it is.

    • You are correct, Kid. I’m certainly not implying that all Facebook users are stupid, but rather that stupid people apparently love Facebook. Thx…

  5. I just read that the first conviction/sentence from the Vancouver Stanley Cup riots has been handed down: Ryan Dickinson got 17 months in jail for throwing a newspaper box onto a police car windshield and smashing a store window – it took eight months, but at last, SOMETHING is being done. A total of 350 charges have been recommended against 125 accused. The Crown has approved 141 criminal charges against just 52 of the suspected rioters. That’s a tiny fraction of the number of thugs, looters, arsonists we watched on tv last June 15TH.

What do you think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s